1. The Luxury Garage Sale
Nestled in the heart of the city, The Luxury Garage Sale isn't your typical garage sale. Imagine stepping into a high-end boutique rather than sifting through old records and dusty comics. This consignment store offers a truly luxurious experience with a carefully curated selection of designer handbags that look as if they’ve just walked off the runway. Here, you’ll find everything from classic Chanel to the ever-elusive Hermes Birkin, sure to light up any fashionista’s face.
Why I Love It
There's something spectacularly serendipitous about stumbling across a sought-after handbag that you thought you’d only see in magazines. The thrill of the hunt in this lavish store feels more like a leisurely treasure hunt. Plus, The Luxury Garage Sale is known for its friendly staff who are ever willing to share the stories behind each bag’s elegant journey.
2. Crossroads Trading
For those who live for the thrill of a good find, Crossroads Trading is a must-visit. This store doesn’t only focus on high-ticket brands but has an eclectic mix of luxury staples and unique indie finds. While the vibes here are more casual, don’t let that fool you. The handbag section features hidden gems waiting for the keen eye.
What to Expect
There’s an air of unpredictability about this shop that adds to its charm. One moment, you might be marveling at a near-mint Gucci Marmont, only to find a delightful vintage piece in the next moment. It’s like a box of chocolates—you never know what you’re going to get!
3. Second Time Around
Finding love the second time around isn't just for our romantic lives—it's true for handbags too. Second Time Around captivates with its charming display of preloved designer handbags, all ready for their new home.
Atmosphere & Ambiance
The boutique atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it easy to get lost in the stories of bags that have "loved before." Rummaging through this store feels akin to a quirky romance film where each bag isn’t just a product, but a character waiting for its sequel.
4. Bottega Veneta Chicago
While not exclusively a consignment store, Bottega Veneta Chicago offers rare finds, especially during their special sales. It’s worth popping by to see if a limited handbag appeared on their shelves.
Insider Insights
Be on the lookout for announcements on special events where they occasionally feature consigned bags or collaborations with artisans. It’s during these times that true magic happens.

5. Encore Resale
Last but certainly not least, Encore Resale, lives up to its name by providing a second chapter for designer handbags and accessories. A visit here guarantees a delightful mix of styles spanning across decades.
Encore Experience
The experience is both nostalgic and refreshing, appealing to those who appreciate the elegance of the past as much as the cutting-edge designs of present.

Now it's your turn to indulge in the excitement of finding designer bags at these amazing consignment stores in Chicago. Which of these excites you most? Whether you're on the hunt for a particular brand or love browsing a diverse range, each of these spots holds a potential for your next great find.